Indochina Airlines still hit by turbulence

The VND25 billion ($1.25 million) bad debt Indochina Airlines owes to aviation fuel supplier Vinapco would have been avoidable if the latter had received more justified instructions from relevant authorities.

Under the Dispatch 2131/CHK-TC dated June 24, 2009 the Civil Aviation Administration of Vietnam (CAAV) asked Vinapco not to stop supplying fuel to Indochina Airlines though the air carrier was a bad debtor. It said that discontinued fuel supply would adversely affect passengers as well as the aviation sector’s overall performance.

CAAV’s decision made the fuel supplier to bear a huge loss of up to $1.25 million.

Since that private airline began flying from early 2009, it had been a persistent bad debtor to Vinapco. However, Vinapco could not unilaterally stop supplying fuel for Indochina Airlines to avoid further debt as under the Competition Law’s item 3, clause 14, Vinapco as the single aviation fuel supplier was forbidden to take advantage of its monopoly to unilaterally cancel contracts.

In the commercial dispute between Vinapco and Indochina Airlines, two relevant management agencies have given out ambiguous instructions.

The Vietnam Competition Authority, an anti-monopoly state agency on economic activities, in its Document 273/QLCR-HCT dated April 28, 2009 said that the settlement of debt between Vinapco and its customers had to follow relevant laws and clauses in the signed contract.

However, it failed to give out a clear response for the question whether Vinapco violated the Competition Law if it stopped supplying fuel to Indochina Airlines.

For its part, CAAV in the instructive document 1369/CHK-TC, proposed Vinapco take appropriate measures to collect debts. However, it also requested the fuel supplier not to pause providing fuel to the airline saying that this could cause big impacts on passengers and the sector’s performance.

“We [Vinapco] are very confused with these equivocal instructions. Vinapco cannot wait for CAAV to considering withdrawal of operational licences of underperformed airlines while seeing our loss mounting up day by day,” said general director Tran Huu Phuc.

Vinapco reportedly sustained a fine of VND3 billion ($150,000) in March 2008 when it unilaterally stopped supplying fuel to Jetstar Pacific Airlines because the latter refused to pay the fuel cost arguing that its fuel cost was overly high.

Aware of the case, on June 23, 2009 Indochina Airlines forwarded the Document 0908/2009/ICA to Vinapco asking the fuel supplier to suspend the debt amount of VND11 billion incurred by that time and promised to pay back when the airline restructured its capital sources in September, 2009.

The airline, however, stopped flying from November 1, 2009 due to losses and debts.

From VietNamBusiness

Newer Articles
  • Mazut oil imports won’t be tax-exempt, says Deputy PM
  • Digital printing industry set to grow in Vietnam
  • Steel industry targets energy saving opportunities
  • Ministry urges EVN not to raise rates more than once per quarter
  • PetroVietnam achieves 67.4 pct of year’s plan
  • Industrial park moves offset FDI downturn
  • Cement industry loses loan guarantees
  • Electricity price should have been raised by 50pct instead of current 15pct
  • Vietnam lacks construction standards for underground car parks
  • Phong Phu and Song Da groups apply for upgrading National Highway No 6
Older Articles
  • European Bank funds HCMC’s urban railway
  • Power shortages loom as projects behind schedule
  • Maintenance contract for Nhon trach 1 power plant inked
  • EVN continues to buy electricity from China
  • $600 million needed for 2011 road building
  • Future power shortages threaten HCM City
  • Decentralisation blamed for mining losses
  • Miner seeks coal price hike
  • Vinashin set to build 20 ships for Vinalines
  • TNK-BP embraces PetroVietnam
Latest News
  • Vietnamese software firms consider Japan as the major market
  • Despite problems, 2011 FDI spending equals 2010
  • EVNTelecom asks for government’s approval to sell 12pct stake for VTC
  • Vietnamese enterprises expanding into international markets
  • Ernst & Young Vietnam role to be examined
  • Vietnamese firms invest over $24.5b in foreign countries as of July-end
  • Vietnam Insurance Market: Keeping Double-digit Growth
  • Vietnam’s economy looks grim with ADB’s forecast
  • Ministry rejects import-export tax changes
  • Government okays anti-dumping suit against US
For Foreigners
  • Adb: policy tightening will lower inflation
  • HSBC, Barclays to advise Vietinbank’s planned overseas dollar bond sale
  • Vietnam govt to service debt for troubled cement projects
  • Calm heads prevail as the forex market to remain cool
  • Further fiscal & monetary tightening in coming months
  • IMF cuts Vietnam’s inflation forecast to 9.5pct in 2011
  • Vietnam’s dong has best week since 1997 after dollar rates curb
  • Vietnam tightens control over state-bank partnership
  • Foreign investors list problems in Vietnam
  • Foreign invested enterprises complain about customs procedures

BusinessTradeVietnamGovernmentFDIWorld economyVietnamese PartyEconomyEconomicMarketState managementPrime MinisterHCM cityHanoiHo Chi MinhCPIAsianWorldAmericaEuropeNguyen Tan DungHau GiangMekong DeltariceStandingMekongCambodiausajapanchinakoreaLai ChauHoa BinhHoi AnChu LaiQuang NamDa nangCan thoSon LaPower PlantMinistry of IndustryDung QuatOilSingaporeThailandMalaysiaIndonesiaLaosVietnameseFDI capitalinvestorsforeign investorNetherlandsUSservicetransportationinfrastructuretourismVNPostExpressSpainGoldTra fishexportcontractstouristMiddle AreaConstructionShipbuildingIndustryCompanyIndustrial ZonebudgetDong NaiBinh DuongVung TauTay NinhBinh PhuocTay NinhLong AnTien GiangUS investorshydropower plantQuang NinhNha TrangStock ExchangeHNXIndexcapitalAgricultureDong ThapAn GiangExport-Processing ZoneYen BaiLao CaiLai ChauDien BienSon LaHoa BinhPhu ThoHa GiangTuyen QuangBac KanLang SonCao BangmanufacturersAseanRussiadevelopmentAviationinflationHong KongAmericanChamber of CommerceSeafoodODAWBIMFFEDAsia-PacificAssociationcountriesEuropeanmarine economyThanh HoaNghe AnNam DinhHa TinhPhu LýVinh PhucBac NinhBac GiangHung YenHai DuongBinh ThuanBinh PhuocLam DongGia LaiKon tumQuang NgaiQuang BinhQuang TriNinh ThuanCa MauBac LieuSoc TrangTra VinhKien GiangVinh LongBen TreincomespoliciesLawassetsNatural GasBuildingstatisticsstrategyDa Latmineral exploitationprocessingindustrieselectricitywatersupplyEnterprisesforestryfisherycommunicationsreal estatetransportationCorruptionbauxiteSecuritiesInsuranceBankFinanceAccountgoodsTrade BalancecoffeeCoalfestivalHa NamNinh BinhHoa BinhUniversityArtsBooktravelVietnam VisaVisaPagodaCommitteePeople's CommitteeVinashincompaniesHoa PhatHSBCACBvietcombankvietinbank

Copyright 2010 © 
Powered by: CIINS Design by: