Ca Na debacle a tough lesson

The government last week officially put the nail in the coffin of Vietnam’s largest registered foreign direct investment project.

According to a Government Office announcement, Prime Minister Nguyen Tan Dung agreed with Ninh Thuan People’s Committee to revoke the investment certificate of the long-delayed $9.8 billion Ca Na steel manufacturing complex project.

The agreement put an end to the so called “illusive project”, which was registered for investment by Malaysia’s Lion Group and financially-troubled Vinashin three years ago.

The case leaves lessons for local authorities, responsible for attracting foreign direct investment (FDI) to their provinces under the government’s decentralisation policy.

“The Ca Na steel manufacturing case reminds provincial authorities of projects’ quality instead of illusive registered capital,” said Cao Ba Khoat, general director at K & Partners Law Firm.

FDI attraction has been booming since 2006, when the government decentralised investment management and licensing to local authorities. However, analysts said many provincial authorities lured poor quality FDI.

“Over the past years, registered capital has been reported as a big achievement at many provinces. Provincial leaders, however, did not care whether the projects were really essential and did not carefully appraise investors’ ability,” said Professor Nguyen Mai, chairman of the Vietnam Association of Foreign Invested Enterprises.

With the registration of the Ca Na steel project with an annual output of 14 million tonnes of steel, Ninh Thuan province was lauded as an outstanding place for FDI in 2008. The Lion Group-Vinashin joint venture held a ground breaking ceremony two months after receiving an investment certificate and announced to finish the project’s first stage in 2010. However, nothing further was done. Ninh Thuan People’s Committee said the two firms had insufficient financial muscle to carry out the project.

The project’s 1,650 hectare site will be offered to the domestic Ocean Energy Development Corporation for developing a deep seaport and industrial parks. However, the total investment capital of those projects has not been revealed.

“The change aims to use land effectively and attract investments for developing the province’s industrial sector in accordance with its economic development plan till 2020,” said a Ninh Thuan People’s Committee announcement.

Those industrial parks will attract manufacturing projects to support the development of nuclear power and wind power plants in Ninh Thuan.

Mai, also former vice chairman of the State Committee for Cooperation and Investment – now the Ministry of Planning and Investment, said local authorities should take lessons from the Ca Na debacle.

“Quality and effectiveness of projects must be the first priority, not registered capital,” he said.

Last year, Quang Nam People’s Committee withdrew the investment certificate of a $4.15 billion recreation resort project, registered by US-based Dragon Beach Group. Phu Yen People’s Committee also cancelled the investment certificate of US-based Galileo Investment Group’s $1.68 billion Creative City project. Both investors are said to be too financially challenged to develop the projects.

From VirVN

Newer Articles
  • EVNTelecom asks for government’s approval to sell 12pct stake for VTC
  • Vietnamese enterprises expanding into international markets
  • Ernst & Young Vietnam role to be examined
  • Vietnamese firms invest over $24.5b in foreign countries as of July-end
  • Vietnam Insurance Market: Keeping Double-digit Growth
  • Vietnam’s economy looks grim with ADB’s forecast
  • Fearing recession in EU, Vietnamese businesses try to seek new markets
  • Rise in bad bank debt exposes economy
  • Tighter spending helps curb inflation
  • Expert predicts inflation at single-digit rate in 2012
Older Articles
  • Registered FDI down, disbursement still up
  • Firms eye new way to attract capital
  • Dollar deposit interest rates start to cool down
  • Gold traders say not expectant of bullion trade this year
  • Optimism over foreign investment
  • January FDI plunges to $187.6 mln
  • Transport must be in harmony with each locality’s conditions
  • Credit hurdles to trip up foreign-backed projects
  • New hopes for FPI in 2011
  • The “Sony effect” among foreign invested enterprises?
Latest News
  • Vietnamese software firms consider Japan as the major market
  • Despite problems, 2011 FDI spending equals 2010
  • EVNTelecom asks for government’s approval to sell 12pct stake for VTC
  • Vietnamese enterprises expanding into international markets
  • Ernst & Young Vietnam role to be examined
  • Vietnamese firms invest over $24.5b in foreign countries as of July-end
  • Vietnam Insurance Market: Keeping Double-digit Growth
  • Vietnam’s economy looks grim with ADB’s forecast
  • Ministry rejects import-export tax changes
  • Government okays anti-dumping suit against US
For Foreigners
  • Adb: policy tightening will lower inflation
  • HSBC, Barclays to advise Vietinbank’s planned overseas dollar bond sale
  • Vietnam govt to service debt for troubled cement projects
  • Calm heads prevail as the forex market to remain cool
  • Further fiscal & monetary tightening in coming months
  • IMF cuts Vietnam’s inflation forecast to 9.5pct in 2011
  • Vietnam’s dong has best week since 1997 after dollar rates curb
  • Vietnam tightens control over state-bank partnership
  • Foreign investors list problems in Vietnam
  • Foreign invested enterprises complain about customs procedures

BusinessTradeVietnamGovernmentFDIWorld economyVietnamese PartyEconomyEconomicMarketState managementPrime MinisterHCM cityHanoiHo Chi MinhCPIAsianWorldAmericaEuropeNguyen Tan DungHau GiangMekong DeltariceStandingMekongCambodiausajapanchinakoreaLai ChauHoa BinhHoi AnChu LaiQuang NamDa nangCan thoSon LaPower PlantMinistry of IndustryDung QuatOilSingaporeThailandMalaysiaIndonesiaLaosVietnameseFDI capitalinvestorsforeign investorNetherlandsUSservicetransportationinfrastructuretourismVNPostExpressSpainGoldTra fishexportcontractstouristMiddle AreaConstructionShipbuildingIndustryCompanyIndustrial ZonebudgetDong NaiBinh DuongVung TauTay NinhBinh PhuocTay NinhLong AnTien GiangUS investorshydropower plantQuang NinhNha TrangStock ExchangeHNXIndexcapitalAgricultureDong ThapAn GiangExport-Processing ZoneYen BaiLao CaiLai ChauDien BienSon LaHoa BinhPhu ThoHa GiangTuyen QuangBac KanLang SonCao BangmanufacturersAseanRussiadevelopmentAviationinflationHong KongAmericanChamber of CommerceSeafoodODAWBIMFFEDAsia-PacificAssociationcountriesEuropeanmarine economyThanh HoaNghe AnNam DinhHa TinhPhu LýVinh PhucBac NinhBac GiangHung YenHai DuongBinh ThuanBinh PhuocLam DongGia LaiKon tumQuang NgaiQuang BinhQuang TriNinh ThuanCa MauBac LieuSoc TrangTra VinhKien GiangVinh LongBen TreincomespoliciesLawassetsNatural GasBuildingstatisticsstrategyDa Latmineral exploitationprocessingindustrieselectricitywatersupplyEnterprisesforestryfisherycommunicationsreal estatetransportationCorruptionbauxiteSecuritiesInsuranceBankFinanceAccountgoodsTrade BalancecoffeeCoalfestivalHa NamNinh BinhHoa BinhUniversityArtsBooktravelVietnam VisaVisaPagodaCommitteePeople's CommitteeVinashincompaniesHoa PhatHSBCACBvietcombankvietinbank

Copyright 2010 © 
Powered by: CIINS Design by: