Auto tax debate continues, business suffer

The debate about whether to tax 2-seat Daewoo Matiz and Kia Morning vehicles as vans or passenger cars, which people thought came to and end, has been resumed.

An importer has accused customs agencies of deliberately delaying procedures to put difficulties on the enterprise.

Customs agencies deliberately put difficulties in enterprises’ way

The Hanoi branch of the Tay Bac Automobile Company has lodged a complaint to the General Department of Customs, saying that its import consignment still has not got customs clearance due to the difficulties raised by the customs agencies.

Tay Bac signed a contract with South Korean HWA SEUNG Network Company on importing 26 Daewoo Matiz cars on October 18, 2010. The import consignment has been getting stuck at the port for one year due to the bureaucracy of the Dinh Vu Port’s and the Hai Phong City Customs Agencies.

“We believe that the imports can meet the requirements to be considered as vans. Therefore, despite the argument about taxing vans and the companies’ risk of paying the tax arrears of 34 billion dong at that moment, we still made customs declarations for the clearance of the 26 imported cars,” said Hung, Director of the Hanoi Branch of the Tay Bac Automobile Company.

“However, on October 26, 2010, when we made customs declarations, the customs agency refused to work on our declarations without any explanations,” Hung said.

After a lot of delays, the Hai Phong City Customs Agency showed Tay Bac the document released by the General Department of Customs signed on November 4, 2010, which asked to delay working on the van imports (Matiz brand) until a new decision is made.

Finally, the company successfully made customs declaration. However, it was November 19, 2010, when changes in the tax policies were made. On November 8, 2010, the Ministry of Science and Technology released a document which amends the regulations on the criteria to defining vans and passenger cars.

“If we had successfully made customs declaration in October, we would have been imposed the tax rate applied to vans,” Hung said

Six months later, the Vietnam Register granted a certificate to Tay Bac, affirming that the 26 imported vehicles were vans. However, the Hai Phong City’s Customs Agency continued pending the import consignment of 26 vans.

“The Hai Phong City’s customs agency deliberately delayed the working on our customs declarations, because it wanted to wait for the new policy which it knew would have stricter regulations,” Hung said.

“The deliberate delay of customs agencies without any legitimate reasons has caused big losses to us,” he continued.

The government inspectors, when reporting to the Prime Minister about the import of Matiz brand vehicles, also proposed to tax the 26 vehicles imported by Tay Bac as vans. However, the issue remains on the shelf.

Different strokes for different folks

The involved parties have to continue debating about whether the imports are vans or passenger cars because there is a big gap in the tax rates imposed on the two kinds of vehicles.

If the imports are considered passenger cars, the importer will have to pay the import tax of 82 percent, the luxury tax of 45 percent and the VAT of 10 percent. Meanwhile, if the imports are considered vans, they will not be imposed luxury tax, while the import tax will be much lower. In the case of Tay Bac, the difference in the tax sums would be 60 million dong

The government inspectors, in a report to the Prime Minister, said that before the Vietnamese standards on classifying cars were adjusted, the Ministry of Finance and General Department of Customs agreed that 2-seat Kia Morning and Daewoo Matiz vehicles, 300 kg in weight were considered five seat passenger cars.

However, in the legal document released prior to November 8, 2010, the Vietnam Register certified that these were vans. The disagreement between customs agencies and the Vietnam Register has made enterprises suffer.

From VietNamBusiness

Newer Articles
  • Milk prices unexpectedly shoot up
Older Articles
  • Milk prices unexpectedly shoot up
  • Vietnam may lose Buon Ma Thuot coffee brand
  • Building materials sales to rise
  • Car sales up 10 per cent in August
  • Domestic retailers tend to join hands with foreign
  • Social networks more utilized by businesses for marketing
  • Fertiliser prices increase dramatically
  • Vietnam’s trade gap from China at nearly $4b in Jan-Apr
  • VCCI supports business restructuring
  • Base year for calculating GDP should be changed, expert says
Latest News
  • Vietnamese software firms consider Japan as the major market
  • Despite problems, 2011 FDI spending equals 2010
  • EVNTelecom asks for government’s approval to sell 12pct stake for VTC
  • Vietnamese enterprises expanding into international markets
  • Ernst & Young Vietnam role to be examined
  • Vietnamese firms invest over $24.5b in foreign countries as of July-end
  • Vietnam Insurance Market: Keeping Double-digit Growth
  • Vietnam’s economy looks grim with ADB’s forecast
  • Ministry rejects import-export tax changes
  • Government okays anti-dumping suit against US
For Foreigners
  • Adb: policy tightening will lower inflation
  • HSBC, Barclays to advise Vietinbank’s planned overseas dollar bond sale
  • Vietnam govt to service debt for troubled cement projects
  • Calm heads prevail as the forex market to remain cool
  • Further fiscal & monetary tightening in coming months
  • IMF cuts Vietnam’s inflation forecast to 9.5pct in 2011
  • Vietnam’s dong has best week since 1997 after dollar rates curb
  • Vietnam tightens control over state-bank partnership
  • Foreign investors list problems in Vietnam
  • Foreign invested enterprises complain about customs procedures

BusinessTradeVietnamGovernmentFDIWorld economyVietnamese PartyEconomyEconomicMarketState managementPrime MinisterHCM cityHanoiHo Chi MinhCPIAsianWorldAmericaEuropeNguyen Tan DungHau GiangMekong DeltariceStandingMekongCambodiausajapanchinakoreaLai ChauHoa BinhHoi AnChu LaiQuang NamDa nangCan thoSon LaPower PlantMinistry of IndustryDung QuatOilSingaporeThailandMalaysiaIndonesiaLaosVietnameseFDI capitalinvestorsforeign investorNetherlandsUSservicetransportationinfrastructuretourismVNPostExpressSpainGoldTra fishexportcontractstouristMiddle AreaConstructionShipbuildingIndustryCompanyIndustrial ZonebudgetDong NaiBinh DuongVung TauTay NinhBinh PhuocTay NinhLong AnTien GiangUS investorshydropower plantQuang NinhNha TrangStock ExchangeHNXIndexcapitalAgricultureDong ThapAn GiangExport-Processing ZoneYen BaiLao CaiLai ChauDien BienSon LaHoa BinhPhu ThoHa GiangTuyen QuangBac KanLang SonCao BangmanufacturersAseanRussiadevelopmentAviationinflationHong KongAmericanChamber of CommerceSeafoodODAWBIMFFEDAsia-PacificAssociationcountriesEuropeanmarine economyThanh HoaNghe AnNam DinhHa TinhPhu LýVinh PhucBac NinhBac GiangHung YenHai DuongBinh ThuanBinh PhuocLam DongGia LaiKon tumQuang NgaiQuang BinhQuang TriNinh ThuanCa MauBac LieuSoc TrangTra VinhKien GiangVinh LongBen TreincomespoliciesLawassetsNatural GasBuildingstatisticsstrategyDa Latmineral exploitationprocessingindustrieselectricitywatersupplyEnterprisesforestryfisherycommunicationsreal estatetransportationCorruptionbauxiteSecuritiesInsuranceBankFinanceAccountgoodsTrade BalancecoffeeCoalfestivalHa NamNinh BinhHoa BinhUniversityArtsBooktravelVietnam VisaVisaPagodaCommitteePeople's CommitteeVinashincompaniesHoa PhatHSBCACBvietcombankvietinbank

Copyright 2010 © 
Powered by: CIINS Design by: